Kirkus Review

In this sequel to a prequel, a third candidate for School Master brings simmering tensions between twins Rhian and Rafal to a boil. In events following close on those in Rise of the School for Good and Evil (2022), the arrival of James Hook in Neverland, along with fellow ex-students Aladdin and Princess Kyma, spurs ruthless tyrant Peter Pan to mount his own bid to take over the twin-towered school where fairy-tale characters are trained. Meanwhile Rafal and Rhian, amid their growing rivalry, are both searching for an ally they can trust, and they kidnap a Reader--young Midas--from the outside world. What follows is a seminar on telling Good from Evil as the line between the two becomes even more muddled, numerous members of the sprawling cast exhibit qualities of both, and Rafal, in particular, suffers an extended identity crisis. Chainani explores feminist themes as a group of punk Neverland fairies and a man-hunting troll join Kyma, asserting their independence and questioning what might happen "if boys don't have the last word in our stories." He also presents a credible rationale for Good's invariable victory over Evil in fairy tales. Characters' skin tones vary from pale to bronze, and the two trolls are colorful showstoppers. Final art not seen. Fans will be pleased to see answers, background, and a clear path to Volume 1. (Fantasy. 11-14) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.