School Library Journal Review
Gr 3-6-After an initially rough start, classroom rat Malcolm has found his place at McKenna School. He is now a valued member of the Midnight Academy and is enjoying life. However, circumstances outside of his control may change everything. The school is falling down around their ears. There is talk of closing it. Malcolm must venture outside in search of a solution, but this choice is not without peril. It turns out that history may be the key to everything. There's a mystery to solve, a code to unravel, human friends to recruit, and an old enemy to face again. Charlotte Parry cozily narrates, creating unique voices for the different characters. VERDICT This is a nicely paced production that will please fans of the series. ["For middle grade readers who enjoy animal adventure tales with many twists and turns": SLJ 8/15 review of the HMH book.]-Teresa Bateman, Brigadoon Elementary, Federal Way, WA © Copyright 2016. Library Journals LLC, a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Horn Book Review
Rat Malcolm (Malcolm at Midnight) belongs to McKenna Elementary's Midnight Academy, a secret society of classroom pets that solves the school's problems at night. When the school board threatens to close McKenna, Malcolm turns to the mysterious "Striped Shadow" and an old enemy to save his beloved community. This combination of animal fantasy, school story, and mystery integrates interesting animal facts into an engaging narrative. (c) Copyright 2016. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted.
Kirkus Review
The critters of the Midnight Academy must find a way to save McKenna Elementary School from destruction. The old building is in desperate need of repair, and funds are not available to take on the monumental task. The Midnight Academy, made up of a variety of unusual, intelligent, and eccentric "inside" animals, is a secret society that has both an immensely detailed collective memory and a deep love of the children and staff, past and present. Malcolm, the fifth grade's lovable pet rat, who can read and is able to communicate with the humans, takes the lead as the Academy works to find a solution that will save the school. Continuing the format of Malcolm at Midnight (2012), the narration again is in the guise of an anonymous report, complete with delightful asides and footnotes, sent to fifth-grade teacher Mr. Binney. Beck takes readers through a labyrinth of secret codes, hidden clues, clandestine meetings with outside animals, promises made and broken, hopeful leads, and crushing disappointments. A time capsule, a roof collapse, and the return of a former enemy add to the twists and turns of a fast-paced roller coaster of a plot. Malcolm's ponderings on the nature of revenge, compassion, loss, and friendship are seamlessly woven into the plot. Lies' gray-toned, textured pencil-and-graphite illustrations add dimension and personality to the creatures. Welcome back, Malcolm. (Animal fantasy. 9-12) Copyright Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Malcolm, the fifth grade's resident rat, discovers a wider world when his beloved but run-down school is threatened with closure. Following the plumbing disaster that climaxed Malcolm at Midnight (2012), a string of power failures, and other much-needed building repairs, it looks like curtains for McKenna Elementary. Crumb! Can the students, aided by Malcolm and the other mascots that make up the nocturnal Midnight Academy, find a way to save the day? Only, as it turns out, by seeking help Outside and also by following hints of hidden treasure in school legends. The former tests the limits not only of Malcolm's courage but also his compassion as he is required to make peace with an old, mad, hated feline adversary. The treasure that finally convinces the school board to keep McKenna open turns out to be the school's own history: There's never enough money, Malcolm rightly sees. What never runs out is story. Lies' naturalistic illustrations enhance the general air of realism in a tale featuring unusually rich thematic underpinnings and a small protagonist with both hero brain and hero heart. --Peters, John Copyright 2015 Booklist
Excerpts
Chapter 1 A Sneeze It began with a sneeze. Malcolm didn't mean to sneeze, but when you're a small rat stuffed into a fifth-grader's jeans pocket, these things happen. Especially if the pocket is, for some unknown reason, filled with pencil shavings. Skylar, the owner of the pocket, jiggled at the sneeze, and Malcolm scrambled to stay upright. Crumb! This was no good. Back in Room 11, when Skylar had held out his hand, Malcolm had jumped at the chance to go with him to the class's rehearsal of the fifth grade program.1 After all, Malcolm had never been to McKenna Elementary School's auditorium before, and it was his duty--as a member of the school's secret society of classroom pets, Midnight Academy--to seize these opportunities when they presented themselves. Besides, Skylar carried Cheezy Bits Snack Crackers in his pocket. It is hard for anyone to think around Cheezy Bits Snack Crackers. But so far this afternoon, all Malcolm had seen was the inside of Skylar's pocket. The other one. The one filled with pencil shavings. Malcolm was beginning to think Amelia had been right to shake her head at Skylar's invitation. Nevertheless, he was here, so he might as well use his eyes, ears, nose, and whiskers to report something back to the Midnight Academy. He fought his way up to the edge of the pocket and stuck his nose out. Ah--already this was better: fresh air. He scanned the view. Skylar and the rest of the fifth-graders (or "nutters," as the Midnight Academy liked to call kids; "lankies" were grownups) swayed to the refrain of "Rocky Top." Kiera, decked out in pink sequins, warbled in the spotlight with a much-coveted solo. Mrs. Findlay paused her piano playing, and the song creaked to a halt. "Kiera, this is not American Idol . Please, just sing. No need to stalk about the stage." The rest of the students--including the two classes waiting in the audience--twittered. Mrs. Findlay wasn't done, though. She snapped her fingers at the back row on the risers. "You--singers in the back. You've got to stand still. The audience can see every little move." She turned and shaded her eyes. "Isn't that right, Mr. Binney?" You sat up from your seat in the front row, Mr. Binney, and frowned. "Yes. What's going on back there? Skylar, do you need to use the restroom?" Skylar wiggled his jeans around his hips, knocking Malcolm back down into the pencil shavings. "Um, what?" The classes in the audience snickered again. Tianna, Kiera's best friend, who happened to be standing next to Skylar on the stage, elbowed him. "Stand still!" she muttered under her breath. "You're making us look bad." Jovahn leaned over from the other side of Skylar. "It's only the fifth grade program, Tianna. Not American Idol , remember? And it's a rehearsal." "It's Malcolm," Skylar said, pushing Malcolm down inside his pocket again. "He keeps poking his head out." At the sound of Malcolm's name, another fifth-grader twisted around from the row in front of Skylar, her long black hair swinging back. "Is he okay? I told you not to bring him!" Amelia Vang whispered. Jovahn held out his hand. "Dude, here. Give him to me." Yes, this was a good idea. Jovahn Grayson probably also had strange things in his pockets, but he was definitely more predictable than Skylar. Malcolm crept out, climbing up to Skylar's shoulder. He was poised to make the leap to Jovahn, when, from high up above--a rustle. Then a low thunk. Malcolm's ears pricked up, and he tilted his head. In the rafters, a shadow shifted. A small shower of dust sprinkled down, and Malcolm's nose twitched. Dirt? And then, with another thunk, the lights winked out, and the auditorium was plunged into darkness. The nutters--onstage and otherwise--shrieked and hooted. In the dark, someone knocked into Skylar, and Malcolm somersaulted off his shoulder. He landed, hunched, on the risers as they rumbled with the feet of thirty panicked fifth-graders. Shoelaces whizzed by Malcolm's whiskers, and he latched on. Better to be on than under this foot. "FREEZE!" Your voice boomed through the darkness, Mr. Binney, and the foot under Malcolm came to a standstill. Malcolm peered in your direction and saw a flashlight beam bobbing in the audience. "Nobody move. The lights will come on again. They always do. It's not like this hasn't happened lately--so SETTLE DOWN." And like you commanded it, the power clicked back on. "See? There." Mrs. Findlay laughed nervously from the piano. "That won't happen during our program tonight, right, Mark?" she asked you. She turned to the class, clapping her hands for attention. "Now--again. From the top." "Actually, Mrs. Findlay"--you were leaping up the stage steps two at a time--"I think that's enough for today. The bell's about to ring." You whispered to her, "Tonight will be better. I promise." As the class thundered off the risers, Amelia looked around. "Where's Malcolm?" she called to Skylar. He patted his pockets, panic blooming on his face. "Relax--I got him," Jovahn said, hopping on one foot so he could untangle Malcolm from his shoelaces on the other. "Oh, good. I was afraid--" A hand clamped down on Jovahn's shoulder. More specifically, your hand, Mr. Binney. "That's not a certain rat from our classroom, is it, Jovahn?" "Uh--well . . . " Just then, Amelia bumped her way over. To anyone else, she looked to be on her way out the door, but in one smooth motion, she grabbed Malcolm, adjusted the hood on her sweatshirt, and tucked him safely there. Jovahn grinned. He held out his empty hands. "Ah--no, in fact!" You nodded. "I see." Then you raised your voice to your best stage level. "Well, I sure hope he gets back to his cage and doesn't find his way out for a long, LONG time." Amelia flinched but kept moving. Whew. For the first time since Skylar had scooped him out of the cage to go to the auditorium, Malcolm took a deep breath and relaxed. It wasn't simply that he was safe in Amelia's hood. It was more than that. It was Amelia. It might partly be the therapeutic qualities of her strawberry shampoo, but mostly Malcolm Knew--knew with a capital K --that if there was anywhere in the world that he belonged, it was with Amelia. He'd do anything for her, and she would do the same for him. As the rest of the class bottlenecked at the side stage door, Ms. Brumble, the night custodian (and your fiancée, Mr. Binney), joined you. "Whoa," she said, trying to hide a smile. "Laugh all you want," you answered, rubbing your hair until it stuck up in spikes. "We have a long way to go before this bunch is ready to leave McKenna for middle school." Deep in Amelia's hood, Malcolm twitched. Leave? Huh? He pushed his nose out. He watched then as you gestured toward the lights. "What's going on, anyway? Sound system blow a fuse?" Ms. Brumble shook her head. "Unfortunately not. That would be easier to fix. No, this is something bigger. I wish we could figure out what's going on. We had to submit a report to the Building and Grounds department. It's going before the school board tonight." At that, Malcolm remembered. The shadow! The dust falling down! He glanced up toward the back corner rafters where he had heard the rustle and the thunk. Then the last bell rang. Amelia merged into the bustling after-school crowd, and Malcolm had to snuggle down into her hood out of sight. He pulled a whisker into his mouth and nibbled as he considered. Had that shadow really moved? It was almost as if something--someone . . . some critter --had been up there. A shiver rattled down Malcolm's spine, all the way to the tip of his tail. Like . . . a cat? Malcolm had only known one cat in his life, but when you're a small rat, one is more than you ever want to know. But it couldn't have been her. That cat--Snip--was gone. It wouldn't be the first time Malcolm had imagined her. Her scratchy voice, overlong claws, and spider breath haunted even Malcolm's best dreams of peanut butter-dipped pretzels. No, it had to have been something else. But if not her, then what? And did it matter? Maybe he did have something to share with the Midnight Academy after all. Maybe before the meeting on Thursday, he could sniff around a little, find out more. Because, really, you meant for him to stay in his cage during the school day, right, Mr. Binney? Excerpted from Malcolm under the Stars by W. H. Beck All rights reserved by the original copyright owners. Excerpts are provided for display purposes only and may not be reproduced, reprinted or distributed without the written permission of the publisher.