School Library Journal Review
K-Gr 3--As she did with Boxitects, Smith offers an upbeat and empathetic foray into maker (and in this case, baker) culture. South Asian--presenting Naveen might only have a tiny bit of baking experience at home, but he's watched enough baking shows to feel quite confident in his skills. So confident, in fact, that when his Baker Makers class tackles creative cakes, Naveen sets out to make the biggest, most delicious, most elaborate cake of all. Forsaking attention to detail in his zeal to create an impressive bake, Naveen quickly faces disaster. Rallied by his classmates, Naveen tries again the next day, only to run into more unexpected results. But this time some creative problem-solving leads to a delicious solution. In the end, Naveen learns the value of planning ahead and the importance of persistence. The brightly colored cartoon illustrations create an enticing class setting that readers will want to join. The book includes the recipe for Naveen's final cake for inspired want-to-be bakers. VERDICT With an emphasis on effort before reward and a sturdy hero, this is a recommended STEAM--related title.--Alia Shields
Kirkus Review
An aspiring baker learns to make the best of his mistakes. This week in Naveen's Bakers Makers Lab, the class will be making creative cakes. Naveen can't wait to whip up his dream concoction: a "twelve-layer space-unicorn cake" capable of breathing fire! Although he's barely baked before, Naveen has learned a lot from cooking shows, looking at pictures of his favorite pastries, and, of course, sampling plenty of sweet treats. So when his teacher gives the class the recipe, he decides that he's experienced enough to rely on his instincts. Unfortunately, his first attempt is a sloppy, terrible-tasting flop. The next day, he decides to follow the class recipe. Naveen's second attempt seems like an improvement until he tries to decorate it, and everything falls apart again. Luckily, with a little creativity and a lot of persistence, Naveen turns his cake into something--or, more accurately, a collection of somethings--that is totally different from what he originally planned. The surprising results are nothing short of scrumptious. With witty, lively text and vibrant colors, Smith tells a story that will reassure young readers worried about trying new things. The book's message isn't groundbreaking, but its approach is fresh and funny. Naveen is cued as South Asian. An entertaining and humorous story about the power of creative thinking. (Picture book. 3-7) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
