Kirkus Review
A teen witch gets caught up in the mysterious deaths claiming her new classmates. After her mother, who was also a witch, died, Tara Maclay's father started believing witches were evil, forbade Tara from exploring that part of herself, and moved their family to Hellborne, Vermont, a town proud of its witch-burning past. Fellow high school senior Baz, a himbo jock, takes Tara under his wing, but not everyone welcomes her with open arms. Tara learns that two students recently died, and she and fellow new student Daphne have been slotted into their classes. When Tara witnesses a third death, she knows these aren't the accidents they appear; something paranormal is at play. She befriends Daphne, who is a witch hunter, and the pair set out to stop the evil before more deaths occur. Tara, a kind witch who stutters, was a lesbian icon on TV's Buffy the Vampire Slayer, and this new tale taking place before she joined the cast fills in her backstory. There are nods to the show and its characters, but this fun and chilling mystery stands completely on its own. Tara's strict dad adds just as much tension to the story as the murders do, and her awkward new-student feelings plus a growing crush on Daphne ground the story with relatable emotions. Tara and Baz are White; Daphne is Black. A beloved Buffyverse character gets to be the hero and find happiness in this enjoyable, witchy tale. (Paranormal. 13-18) Copyright (c) Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Like her mother, Tara Maclay is a witch. But after her mother dies, Tara's father--who believes witches are possessed by evil demons--moves her from Omaha to Vermont, far away from everything familiar. Now, Tara's slated to go to the semi-famous Hellborne Academy, where, every year at homecoming, they "burn" a witch to celebrate the town's founding. Then Tara gets caught up in a string of very real murders and catches the eye of unfriendly popular girl Elaine--and she can feel dark magic coming from both. Making things worse (but also better?) is gorgeous Daphne Frost, who could be Tara's first real friend in Hellborne, or even her first girlfriend, if she gets out alive. Poston is best known for the Geekerella series, and there's a lot of crossover between her fans and fans of this favorite Buffy the Vampire Slayer character, especially as interest in Buffy has been rejuvenated. A fantasy hit for any witch or vampire lover, this will also appeal to queer readers and adults who grew up with Buffy.
