Available:*
Library | Material Type | Item Barcode | Shelf Number | Status |
---|---|---|---|---|
Searching... Avon-Washington Township Public Library | Teen Fiction Book Hardback | 120791001420170 | T AVI | Searching... Unknown |
Bound With These Titles
On Order
Summary
Summary
Edward and Meg are like night and day, oil and water. Meg zigs while Edward zags. How could two such different people be twins? Well, they are, but they don't have to like it -- or each other.
Seventh grade means different schools for the pair: Brainy Meg's at ultracompetitive Fischer, while Charlton Street Alternative School is the place for freewheeling Edward. Oddly enough, it's just when Edward and Meg are finally out of each other's shadows that the trouble begins.
Within just a week, Meg's aspirations for popularity, imaginary boyfriend, and angst over a terrible yellow ensemble her mother has chosen combine with Edward's devious planning, lack of singing ability, and top-secret soft spot to set off a showdown the likes of which twindom has never before seen.
How is it, then, that this final showdown is so much fun? Could it be that Meg and Edward are more alike than they thought?
Never mind. Read the book!
Reviews (4)
Publisher's Weekly Review
"Collaborating on a novel alternately narrated by seventh-grade twins, Avi and Vail invent a sit-comish plot but redeem it by endowing their characters with strong voices and relaying their mishaps with plenty of wit," said PW. Ages 10-up. (May) (c) Copyright PWxyz, LLC. All rights reserved
Horn Book Review
(Middle School) In alternating chapters, Rachel Vail and Avi take on the personae of fraternal twins with nothing in common except their disdain for each other. ""It is just a quirk of fate that we shared a womb way back in fetus-hood,"" says Meg, an athletic, straight-A seventh grader with low self-esteem who hopes to get picked for the High Achievers Club at school. Her twin brother Edward, a scrawny underachiever with a smart mouth, goes to a different middle school, which is why Meg, on the phone with the ultra-popular founder of the High Achievers Club, can pretend her twin is a suave rock musician (the real Edward ""can't even hum on key"") named Ted. Meg doesn't know that Edward is listening in on her conversation, and his plot to keep her out of the club escalates the deception to the point that the nonexistent Ted's nonexistent band, called Never Mind, gets booked to play at the popular girl's party. As screwball comedies go, this one is consistently entertaining, and the dual narrators remain sympathetic and genuine-sounding even as the plot's convolutions reach absurd levels. Of course, the twins end up with a new appreciation for each other, and popularity ends up seeming much less desirable than being okay with who you are. (c) Copyright 2010. The Horn Book, Inc., a wholly owned subsidiary of Media Source, Inc. No redistribution permitted. All rights reserved.
Kirkus Review
Avi and Vail pair up in this often hilarious and sometimes poignant comedy of errors starring 12-year-old dueling fraternal twins. On the surface, Edward and Meg couldn't be more different--"like night and day," as their mother says. Separately, they are struggling to figure out who they are as individuals. The story unfolds in Manhattan in just five days, shortly after they've started seventh grade--Meg at a school for highly gifted students, and Edward at Charlton Street Alternative. What starts out as a way for Meg to appear cool--she reinvents her "immature, runty, underachiever" brother as a "brilliant, rock/classical bass player" in a hip band--and for Edward to embarrass his sister, escalates into screwball comedy. Surprised by what happens, they realize they have more in common than they thought, and also emerge with a stronger sense of themselves as individuals. The authors explore complicated early adolescent dilemmas and conflicts with comedic agility. It's a real collaboration; the alternating voices of their characters ring true, and the narrative is seamless. (Fiction. 10-14) Copyright ©Kirkus Reviews, used with permission.
Booklist Review
Gr. 5-7. Meg and Edward are twins, but they couldn't be more different and they don't get along. She is tall, smart, and pretty, and she has just been invited to joint the High Achievers' Club at her special middle school. He is the world's biggest loser, an immature, runty underachiever. She is terrified her fancy friends will find out about him. Two of today's best writers tell the story in the twins' alternating narratives, and they have a huge amount of fun with a plot that cuts down the high-achiever snobs and reveals how smart people can fall for their own vain fantasies. Edward shows that his clever sister is not too swift, and his narrative is hilarious--wry, touching, and very smart. The dialogue is great, especially the conversations that reveal how hard it is to listen and to say what you mean. The twins' caring parents talk to Meg about the need to communicate, but they don't listen when she tries to tell them she lied. Don't look too closely at the plot; it's too farcical to be really credible. But the wit and slapstick carry the story, which has moments of sadness that raise serious issues everyone will recognize. Best of all is the message: laugh at yourself. Readers will. --Hazel Rochman Copyright 2004 Booklist